How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye

  Reading time 8 minutes

Understanding Why Mascara Smudges

The quest for smudge-free lash beauty begins with an understanding of the factors that contribute to this irksome problem. Our skin naturally produces oils that could cause makeup to break down over time, leading to the dreaded under-eye smudge. Ensuring your eye area is primed properly can help create a barrier that helps prevent this breakdown.

The Role of Skincare and Oils

A meticulous skincare routine is essential for any makeup application, but when it comes to the eyes, it’s all about balance. Hydrated skin helps keep the area supple and can prevent makeup from flaking; however, too much moisture could also make the skin under the eyes too slick for mascara to adhere properly. Gentler, oil-free moisturizers or specialized eye primers will help create the perfect canvas, allowing for mascara to cling to lashes for longer periods without smudging.

Eye primers go one step further in this process by providing a mattifying effect that not only helps keep the skin at bay from interfering with your mascara but also helps in enhancing the pigment and longevity of your eye makeup.

The Impact of Eye Shape and Movement

Certain eye shapes and the way we express ourselves might cause more frequent smudging. For example, those with deeper set or hooded eyes might find that their lashes touch the skin under their eyebrows more often, transferring mascara in the process. Being aware of your eye shape and how it interacts with your mascara application can help you tailor your approach to prevent smudging.

Authentic 49ers Pro Shop  | How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye

Choosing the Right Mascara

The battle against smudging mascara often begins in the cosmetics aisle. When contemplating the array of choices, one must consider the formula’s propensity to endure the day’s challenges without surrendering to the under-eye area.

Waterproof vs. Water-Resistant Mascara

  1. Waterproof Mascara: Ideal for those prone to eye allergies, sports enthusiasts, or anyone who may find themselves in sentimental moments. Its robust composition does not succumb easily to moisture.
  2. Water-Resistant Mascara: This type is more suited for day-to-day wear with moderate resistance to moisture. It’s easier to remove than its waterproof counterpart.

The Importance of Formulation and Brush Type

Mascara TypeBenefitsIdeal for
VolumizingThickens lashes, more dramatic lookThose with thin or sparse lashes
LengtheningElongates lashesShort lashes seeking a subtle, natural enhancement
CurlingHelps lashes to stay curledStraight lashes that need a lift
FiberAdds length and volumeAchieving a false-lash effect without the falsies
TubingForms tubes around each lashEasy removal and minimal smudging

Alongside these types, the brush itself plays a role. A rubber bristled brush helps prevent clumping, which can help stop smudging as clumps are more likely to fall. Conversely, a more traditional bristled brush might cause more volume but requires a steadier hand to prevent excess from straying.

Authentic 49ers Pro Shop  | How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye

Application Techniques to Prevent Smudging

Step-by-Step Guide to Applying Mascara

  1. Start by curling your lashes with an eyelash curler to create a foundation that lifts away from the under-eye area.
  2. Wipe off any excess product from the mascara wand on a tissue to avoid over-application.
  3. Apply mascara by wiggling the brush at the base of the lashes to deposit color without pushing too much onto the tips.
  4. Use a light hand to apply additional coats and avoid the tips to minimize weigh-down, which can lead to smudging.
  5. Allow each coat to dry a bit before applying the next coat for better adherence and less likelihood of smudging.
  6. Use a clean mascara wand or an eyelash comb to separate lashes after each application to prevent clumping.

Additional Tips and Tricks

  • Dusting loose powder or a specific under-eye setting powder on the area can absorb excess oils and create a matte barrier beneath your lashes.
  • Avoid applying mascara to the lower lashes if you’re prone to smudging; instead, opt for tight-lining the lower waterline with a waterproof liner for definition.
  • Consider using a mascara shield or a business card held behind the lashes when applying to prevent accidental marks on the skin.
  • Dab a bit of waterproof eyeshadow primer on the tips of your lashes as well before applying mascara, which adds extra staying power.

Aftercare and Touch-up Strategies

Maintaining Your Mascara Throughout the Day

  • Refrain from touching or rubbing your eyes, as this is a surefire way to cause smudging.
  • Carry blotting papers or a small powder compact to gently dab away any oils that might crop up during the day.
  • If you spot a smudge, wait for it to dry before gently flaking it away with a cotton swab or dry brush.

Quick Fixes for Smudging

  • Keep a mini pack of makeup remover wipes or a pointed cotton swab dipped in makeup remover for targeted correction.
  • A touch-up concealer can work wonders for covering up any mistakes without disturbing the rest of your makeup.
Authentic 49ers Pro Shop  | How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye


Sporting a flawless mascara application that lasts all day doesn’t have to be a myth. With the right selection of waterproof mascaras, the inclusion of eye primers in your routine, and a mindful application process, you can bid farewell to under-eye smudging. Remember, what works for one person might not work for another, so it’s worth experimenting with different products and techniques to uncover the perfect combination for your unique eyes. The tips and strategies discussed here will help stabilize your makeup looks and keep your confidence as high as your beautifully coated lashes.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: Can waterproof mascara be damaging to my lashes?

A1: Waterproof mascara has a reputation for being tougher to remove, which can sometimes lead to increased lash fallout if not removed gently. However, using an oil-based makeup remover and applying it with a soft touch can minimize any potential damage to your lashes.

Q2: What is the best way to remove waterproof mascara without causing damage?

A2: Investing in a quality dual-phase or oil-based makeup remover is key. Soak a cotton pad with the remover, hold it against your closed eyelid for a few seconds to dissolve the mascara, then gently wipe away without rubbing too harshly.

Q3: How often should I replace my mascara to prevent irritation and smudging?

A3: It’s advisable to replace your mascara every 3-6 months because the product can harbor bacteria over time, which can lead to eye irritation. Additionally, as mascara dries out, it becomes more prone to flaking and smudging.

Q4: Are there certain ingredients in mascaras that are more likely to smudge?

A4: Mascaras that contain oils or are fiber-based may smudge more easily under the eyes as they interact with your skin’s natural oils or if fibers fall. Look for oil-free formulas and tubing mascaras designed to resist smudging.

Q5: Can allergies contribute to my mascara smudging?

A5: Absolutely. Allergies often lead to watery eyes or frequent rubbing, which can cause even some waterproof mascaras to smudge. Seeking treatment for allergies or using allergy-friendly makeup might be necessary steps to maintain your makeup’s integrity throughout the day.

Related Posts

Authentic 49ers Pro Shop  | How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye

Dinner date outfit ideas

  Reading time 12 minutes When the occasion calls for a memorable evening, choosing the right ensemble for dating outings can be as tantalizing as the dinner itself. Whether you’re…

Authentic 49ers Pro Shop  | How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye

Nail ideas with glitter

  Reading time 11 minutes Nails sprinkled with a dash of glitter were once just a festive trend, but they’ve now become a year-round fashion statement that transform the ordinary…

Authentic 49ers Pro Shop  | How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye

How to remove matte lipstick without makeup remover

  Reading time 6 minutes Understanding Matte Lipstick and Removal Challenges Matte lipsticks provide an attractive, long-lasting, and velvety finish that’s become a staple in beauty routines. However, their staying…

Authentic 49ers Pro Shop  | How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye

How Do You Know if Your Skin Barrier is Damaged?

  Reading time 8 minutes The skin barrier is the body’s first line of defense against the environment, shielding us from harmful pollutants, ultraviolet rays, and bacteria. When this protective…

Authentic 49ers Pro Shop  | How to prevent mascara from smudging under your eye

Why Is My Tattoo Raised and Itchy After 3 Years

  Reading time 9 minutes If you find yourself puzzled because your tattoo is raised and itchy after several years, you’re not alone. Can your body reject tattoo ink years…